by MarkM » Tue Oct 23, 2012 6:06 pm
Thank you, thank you, THANK YOU, gentlemen, for researching this and clearing it up for me, and for us all. My thoughts are that I was leaning toward putting this brace in anyway. From an engineering standpoint (caution: I'm NOT), the biggest concern is not the compression tube being strong enough, but rather sideways (bending) loads being applied to the tube back-and-forth, hundreds of times every flight, eventually causing fatigue in that thin wall tube, which is hiding inside a fabric-covered wing and hard to inspect. In a typical homebuilt (which doesn't fly much) this probably won't be a problem... but why take the chance? We're talking about less than $5 worth of tubing, maybe couple hour's work, and a couple of ounces of weight. For that, why not?
Thanks also for starting the new thread, Doug. I'll keep in mind when naming any new threads I post to stick to the subject; it makes it easier for others to search later. Of course this also underscores the importance of this forum, where we clear up confusion and address plans omissions and boo-boos. When in doubt about something, ask!
Mark Matelski
HC-077
N429MM
Thank you, thank you, THANK YOU, gentlemen, for researching this and clearing it up for me, and for us all. My thoughts are that I was leaning toward putting this brace in anyway. From an engineering standpoint (caution: I'm NOT), the biggest concern is not the compression tube being strong enough, but rather sideways (bending) loads being applied to the tube back-and-forth, hundreds of times every flight, eventually causing fatigue in that thin wall tube, which is hiding inside a fabric-covered wing and hard to inspect. In a typical homebuilt (which doesn't fly much) this probably won't be a problem... but why take the chance? We're talking about less than $5 worth of tubing, maybe couple hour's work, and a couple of ounces of weight. For that, why not?
Thanks also for starting the new thread, Doug. I'll keep in mind when naming any new threads I post to stick to the subject; it makes it easier for others to search later. Of course this also underscores the importance of this forum, where we clear up confusion and address plans omissions and boo-boos. When in doubt about something, ask!
Mark Matelski
HC-077
N429MM